Blog
Falling into the performance trap
The water industry is used to architects and designers using generic specifications based on product performance, rather than a specific brand’s product. This is because it brings benefits such as a transparent procurement process, plus greater flexibility for distributors and contractors alike.
The widespread use of open specifications is highlighted by research commissioned by us, here at Marshalls Civils & Drainage. From our survey of 120 industry professionals from across the water infrastructure supply chain, 58.3% of respondents confirmed that specifications are typically generic, while only 20% said they usually specify the manufacturer.
However, it is arguable that this approach is creating downstream danger of delays to a project – and in extreme cases, delivery failure. This is because a broad specification simply shifts decision-making down the project pipeline. In practice, this increased responsibility can translate into higher risk.
Think systems, not components
A recent industry trend is for projects to become more outcomes driven. This means that all elements of the value chain need to have full confidence in the performance, reliability and durability of the systems they design, procure and install. This is where the tried and tested method of open specification is falling down: fundamentally, it is focused on component performance rather than the performance of the full system.
Specifying for the performance of the components rather than the complete system creates risk that the system will not perform as required. Put simply, in this scenario we do not know enough about how the components will interact with each other, or whether products from different brands are truly compatible with each other.
At present, systems too often sit outside of the scope of validation, because the onus is on a broad, performance-based specification for each of its components. Unless the entire system is validated during the design phase, the project is, in essence, flying blind. Yes, it might all work out on site, but equally there is significant risk around both system compliance and performance. This also directly contradicts the industry’s changing priorities.
This is reflected in our recent research, where respondents rated reliable, consistent performance as the most important factor in their product decisions. This metric scored 4.69 out of five – compare that to competitive pricing, which ranked significantly lower with a score of 4.37. This shows us that attitudes are changing. Cost is still key consideration, but it is not as highly prized as confidence in performance.
Confidence, certainty, and compatibility
Given that the industry is asking for reliable, predictable systems, surely we need to include this in the specification stage, rather than leaving it to chance?
In fact, our research indicates that many professionals already feel this way. From our respondents, 68% said they would see value in a single manufacturer capable of supplying both surface-water and underground drainage products, with compatibility identified as the leading reason for this view. It shows us that specifying products and systems is not just about streamlining procurement; it reflects a desire for confidence in both components and the systems they are destined for.
It is important to state that this is not a criticism of contractors. Many can comfortably manage final product selection and system assembly on site. However, capability can vary between contractors – and even more so between site teams. Furthermore, contractors are already under plenty of pressure as it is, with project timelines and margins becoming increasingly tight. The site is also at the sharp end of the project, meaning it is where problems come at a higher cost. Therefore, leaving these decisions to contractors can become somewhat of a lottery. That’s why it makes more sense to de-risk during the design phase.
Addition, not replacement
This is not an argument for the complete replacement of generic specifications, as they still have a vital role to play. But in many cases, we need to be cautious of the consequences that broad component specification can bring to projects for bigger systems.
The research from Marshalls Civils & Drainage reveals that the industry wants confidence and certainty at a system level. That could mean specifying a single supplier, or greater collaboration between brands. And if you want to keep the specification generic, ensure the design phase includes performance metrics at a system level. Either way, one thing is clear: a simple change to specification can bring huge benefits to project delivery success.